banner ad
Experts Logo

articles

Hummingbird Syndrome: Why Disasters Occur

Hummingbird Syndrome: Why Disasters Occur

By: Luiz Hargreaves, AAS, MD, Msc
Tel: 55+(61) 9655-6608
Email Dr. Hargreaves
View Dr. Hargreaves Curriculum Vitae.


There once was a fire in a forest, the animals were in panic… they saw a hummingbird going towards the river, picking up some water in order to try to extinguish the fire. He repeated this gesture frequently and thoroughly.

When the other animals saw the gesture of the kiss-flower, the Lion asked him, “Hummingbird, what are you trying to do? The Hummingbird replied, “I am fighting the flames.” To which the Lion responded, “Do you realize you cannot put out the fire out with just your effort?” The Hummingbird said, “But, at least, I'm doing my best.”

This story has been told by many as an example to be followed, with the idea being that we should always do our best, regardless of what the others may do. From the standpoint of managing emergencies and disasters, the actions of the hummingbird often cause disasters. However, several lessons can be learned from this small story.

  • The hummingbird did not follow a previously defined Disaster Plan, which should have been constantly checked and all the animals should have trained according to the Disaster Plan.
  • The animals did not work as a team.
  • The hummingbird ignored the actions taken by other animals, which could result in duplication of efforts
  • He worked alone, without following any protocol or command set.

Therefore, he has used ineffective measures (he failed to extinguish the fire) and probably watched the forest burn down in flames, perhaps causing the deaths of many animals, and possibly himself. Using this story we can draw a parallel with real life disaster preparedness and emergency response.

What has just been described is called “the Hummingbird Syndrome.” The Hummingbird Syndrome describes a crisis situation with no previous plans for preparedness, mitigation or prevention. In these situations, many people flee and some act as the “Hummingbird,” acting on their own instincts, based only on their beliefs. In most cases, they believe they are being useful and effective in their methods. The result will probably be disastrous.

Many disasters can be avoided. By definition, disasters are critical situations where the response capability is lower than the magnitude of the main event. A small fire managed without the good practices can lead to a major disaster.

We can classify crises and disasters, didactically, in four phases: Pre-impact, Impact, Post-impact, and Recovery.

We live permanently in the Pre-impact phase, waiting for the next crisis or disaster. The question is not if they will occur but, where, when and why. We often believe in a Post-disaster phase, the worst has gone, forgetting that this phase coincides with the Pre-impact of the next event.

Some of the activities that precede the Impact phase are, prevention, preparedness, assessment of vulnerabilities, threats and risks assessments, monitoring of critical situations, mitigation preparation, preparation of business continuation plans, and disaster and/or contingency training. In other words, what we should be doing now in order to avoid the next disaster.

Applied to any crisis, vulnerabilities that are superficially analyzed, threats that are unrecognized or underestimated, in environments where there is no culture of preparedness and prevention for critical situations, invariably result in serious crises and disasters. When this occurs, the Hummingbird will probably be remembered as a hero, but will be victim of the inefficiency of the system which has failed to prevent disaster. It will be too late. It is up to friends of the Hummingbird to tell of his courage, but, however, he will have died in vain…


Luiz Hargreaves, AAS, MD, MS, MA is a qualified Expert in Crisis Management and Disaster Preparedness. He has been working in these fields for more than 30 years, with a large experience in major events, counterterrorism, disaster prevention and emergency planning.

©Copyright - All Rights Reserved

DO NOT REPRODUCE WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION BY AUTHOR.

Related articles

luiz_hargreaves_photo.jpg

1/27/2016· Crisis Management

Self-dispatching in Emergencies and Disasters

By: Dr. Luiz Hargreaves

As an emergency professional, we are prepared to deal with unexpected situations, including disasters. Every time we hear about potential or real crisis, we automatically review the procedures in our minds and the desire to help is enormous. On many occasions, I would like to go directly to a scene to assist the victims and my peers. I believe that this feeling is not different among everyone involved in this field.

luiz_hargreaves_photo.jpg

9/9/2015· Crisis Management

Mass Casualties Related to Major Events Since 1900: Why the Tragedies Are Still Happening

By: Dr. Luiz Hargreaves

In 1903, a fire killed more than 600 people in the Iroquois Theater in Chicago. Most of the victims were children. Among the causes of this tragedy were inadequate emergency exits, insufficient and poorly signposted, overcrowding, lack of fire protection equipment and even suspicion of bribery of persons responsible for overseen the safety conditions of the Theater.

luiz_hargreaves_photo.jpg

2/11/2013· Crisis Management

The Blacksmith, the Nail, the Horse and Disaster Prevention

By: Luiz Hargreaves

The proverb above has received different versions, including this one credited to Benjamin Franklin. A kingdom lost because of a nail. We could also say, a disaster caused by a simple problem that could have been avoided.

;
Experts.com-No broker Movie Ad
Unicourt Logo Button

Follow us

linkedin logo youtube logo rss feed logo