By: Robert Capwell, RIMS-CRMP
Tel: 412-262-9191
Email
Mr. Capwell
Attorneys often use evidence and eyewitnesses when presenting court cases. But an expert witness who provides insider knowledge and credible, convincing testimony can help attorneys win cases. However, the wrong expert witness can potentially break a case.
An expert witness is a professional in a specific field or industry. Attorneys hire expert witnesses to examine research, make an evaluation, and present their professional opinion about their findings.
Consider the employment screening and background check industry - it’s niche, complicated, and filled with regulations, process, and varying federal and state guidelines. It’s critical that an attorney hires a verified subject matter expert witness within the employment screening and background check industry who is credible, knowledgeable, and effective in delivering testimony that can support your case.
Here are several key factors to look for in a background check expert witness:
A background check expert witness requires deep and specific knowledge about the employment screening process, including federal and state guidelines, industry practices, and technical standards. The witness must demonstrate familiarity with the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA), state laws specific to background screening, and the types of data sources used in the background check process.
The federal, state, and local legal requirements for conducting compliant background checks constantly evolve. An expert witness in background screening must have long- standing knowledge of the employment screening industry, including continuous education through the Professional Background Screening Association (PBSA). Attorneys should seek a background check expert witness who has a thorough understanding of the PBSA’s Background Screening Agency Accreditation Program. Knowledge of this program confirms an expert witness grasp all operational aspects of a background check provider and understands how a consumer reporting agency must follow industry-recognized practices to be accredited.
Look for an expert witness in background screening with previous experience testifying in court or providing depositions or testimony related to background screening. This experience is crucial as it means the expert will likely be comfortable and persuasive under cross-examination.
Checking the expert's professional reputation and obtaining references from other attorneys or firms that have used the expert can provide insights into their reliability and effectiveness in court. Conduct a comprehensive background check on your background check expert witness to validate they have the industry knowledge, experience, and clean criminal history you are looking for in someone who can support your case.
Background check expert witnesses are experts for a reason. They are likely published in peer-reviewed journals or have contributed to industry discussions, articles, and presentations on background screening. Attorneys may ask their expert witness in background screening to provide a Curriculum Vitae (CV) as proof of their industry expertise.
Relevant educational qualifications or experience in criminal justice, human resources, law, or data management can add to the credibility of an expert witness in background screening. The expert must have vast knowledge of employment and education verification standards along with a comprehensive understanding of the United States criminal and civil court system.
A background check expert witness should be seen as unbiased and impartial. They must be able to present facts and their professional opinion without any appearance of favoring one side. Seek out an expert that can provide insights based on facts no matter if they are working on behalf of a plaintiff or defense counsel.
An effective background check expert witness must be able to explain complex information in a clear, concise, and accurate manner. Solid communication skills will help to ensure the judge and jury understand the testimony. Look for a background screening expert witness who has successfully delivered presentations and speeches to various audiences.
The expert should be available to discuss the case, prepare a report, and testify as needed. Their willingness to commit time and effort to the case is crucial to helping them achieve a successful outcome.
**********
The information published within is provided for education purposes only. The information is not intended to or constitute legal advice; instead, all information, content, and materials are published for general informational purposes only and not considered the views of a particular expert or consultant of Capwell Consulting Group, LLC.
Copyright © 2022-2025 www.capwellconsulting.com.
Robert Capwell, RIMS-CRMP, is a is a nationally recognized Background Screening and Background Check litigation expert witness leveraging more than three decades of employment screening executive leadership experience. Widely recognized for his deep subject matter expertise on employment screening, Mr. Capwell specializes in providing background check testimony and support for litigation involving the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA), Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC), workplace violence, and negligent hiring and retention.
©Copyright - All Rights Reserved
DO NOT REPRODUCE WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION BY AUTHOR.
5/30/2021· Expert Witnessing
As An Expert Witness, Avoid Implicating In Hypothetical Examples
By: Beth Mohr, CFE, CAMS, CCCI
Certified Fraud Examiners build solid careers by considering all potential legal pitfalls, anticipating problems and taking opportunities to educate others about CFEs’ roles and responsibilities. For example, were precluded from opining about the legal guilt or innocence of any party in any of our cases…
5/29/2003· Expert Witnessing
Avoiding Ipse Dixit Mislabeling: Post-Daubert Approaches To Expert Clinical Opinions
By: Harold Bursztajn, MD and Thomas G. Gutheil, MD
Recent Supreme Court decisions emphasize the need to regulate the admissibility of expert testimony by means of standards that require opinions going beyond ipse dixit; that is, that are based on more than the fact that the expert "said it him/herself
10/17/2017· Expert Witnessing
By: Greg Gerganoff
The employ of expert witnesses in litigation is typically undertaken to help the decider of fact (judge or jury) decipher an area of specialized knowledge which is key to the case. The expert report serves the primary purpose of "educating" deciders of fact on topics not commonly known to the general public. However, a noncomplying expert report can wreak havoc on a case, increase costs or worse, have the expert's testimony precluded in whole or part from use at trial. This of course is contrary to the purpose of retaining an expert in the first place. Understanding the parameters of compliance (C.R.C.P. 26 (a) (2) (B) (I)) and how sanctions for non-compliance (C.R.C.P. 37 (c) (1)) may be applied is important not only for legal counsel but the expert as well under the 2015 rule updates and the recent Colorado Supreme Court case, Catholic Health Initiatives Colorado v. Earl Swensson Associates, Inc.
