banner ad
Experts Logo


A Worthwhile Investment: A Lack of Oversight on Safety Issues Can Cost You Millions in Damages if Students are Hurt

A Worthwhile Investment: A Lack of Oversight on Safety Issues Can Cost You Millions in Damages if Students are Hurt

By: Dr. Edward Dragan

As Originally Published In American School Board Journal, December, 2009

Tel: (609) 397-8989
Email Dr. Dragan

The safety of children is of the utmost concern to school board members, administrators, and teachers. Accidents do happen, of course, but you must do everything you can to make sure that the students in your care are not hurt. A lack of oversight on safety issues can cost districts millions of dollars in the damages awarded each year to families of children injured at school. Consider the following:

  • A third-grade teacher told two students to return a television on a cart to the library down the hall. One student rode the cart, and when the other student lost his grip, the television toppled off and landed on the child's head. The child was in a coma for two weeks and suffered permanent brain damage. The television was not strapped down, and the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission had issued a warning about the cart years earlier. The jury awarded the student's family $1.7 million.
  • A shop class saw malfunctioned, causing a high school student to lose three fingers on his right hand when he cut a piece of wood on a table saw. The teacher had replaced a bolt in the mechanism that shields the operator's hand with one that did not meet the manufacturer's specifications. The accident happened when the bolt loosened. Taking what seemed like a harmless shortcut cost the school district nearly $1 million in a court settlement.
  • An inner-city first-grade teacher needed more storage space, and so she jumped at a friend's offer of a metal bookcase and cabinet. For months, there was no problem- until a child was pushed into the bookcase's sharp, rusty corner. The wound required numerous stitches, and the child also was at risk for tetanus because of the rust. Failing to inspect or regulate furniture in classrooms cost the district more than $200,000 in a settlement.

A safe school is a place where students learn and teachers teach in an environment free of physical hazards. It is a setting in which the school pays attention to maintaining equipment and correcting the sometimes hidden hazards that can injure children and others, cause the district embarrassment, and cost large sums of money.

Unnecessary risks in schools must be corrected, firstly and most importantly, to protect the safety of students and staff. They also must be corrected to avoid costly litigation, verdicts, and settlements. Although insurance companies usually pay these settlements, schools and taxpayers ultimately shoulder the burden in the form of higher taxes, expensive legal fees, insurance premium hikes, or even loss of coverage.

Tips for preventing problems

Most safety violations can be prevented through proactive risk management. Teachers and administrators must learn to scrutinize their procedures, equipment use, and personnel practices to ensure the safety of everyone in the school environment. An obvious but all-too-often overlooked example is playground or gym equipment, where numerous injuries can be prevented with proper maintenance.

Safety tips for risk management include:

  • Inspect the school buildings and premises for evidence of hazards with potential for injury to students, staff, and visitors.
  • Establish an inspections log in which observations of potential hazards are recorded, along with actions taken to eliminate the hazards.
  • Assess potential risk related to the use of equipment in the following areas: playground or gym, sports, media center (library and audiovisual carts, televisions), theatrical or television production sets, laboratories, cafeteria (tables, shelving), and other locations.
  • Establish a safety handbook detailing procedures for supervising students in the classroom, on playing fields, at special school events, in eating areas, on school buses, and in hallways.
  • Conduct in-service training and review what staff should look for in classrooms and other locations in the school, how to record potential safety hazards, and how to know when these hazards have been corrected.
  • Establish a prioritized action plan for making corrections based on reported safety hazards and unsafe practices.
  • Develop a risk analysis plan to identify problem areas with the potential for rendering the school vulnerable to lawsuits.
  • Review any past lawsuits to determine the proximate cause of the injury and develop safeguards sufficient to prevent such accidents from recurring.
  • Model and emphasize personal accountability and commitment to creating safe school procedures.

Boards of education that hold superintendents and other key administrators responsible for implementing these steps demonstrate a commitment to shielding everyone in their school from harm. The result will be safer schools for students, teachers, and visitors-and vastly reduced liability.

Dr. Edward Dragan, provides education expert consultation for high-profile and complicated cases. As an educator and administrator, he has more than 35 years' experience as a teacher, principal, superintendent and director of special education. He also has served as a state department of education official.

©Copyright - All Rights Reserved


Related articles


10/5/2018· Accident Prevention & Safety

Sometimes the Rules Are Wrong: Questioning Common Sense

By: David Curry, John Meyer and Mary Pappas

The public looks to safety professionals for guidance as experts in risk avoidance and hazard mitigation. This is reasonable as they are ostensibly trained in that area and, thus, in a better position to evaluate the risks inherent in different activities and to assess what can and should be done to alleviate or reduce those risks to an acceptable level. As such, it behooves safety professionals to be aware of not only safety-related heuristics that are presented to the public, but also the research that underlies that guidance to assess the appropriateness of the various safety rules that are promulgated to address potential hazards. In the real world, however, ostensible safety experts often simply accept these rules as representing appropriate, normal or typical behavior based on longevity, common sense or the simple frequency with which they are expressed.


2/13/2014· Accident Prevention & Safety

Air Bag Deployment Criteria

By: Dr. Kenneth Solomon

Air bag control modules utilize complex algorithms to make air bag deployment decisions based on crash severity related to the change in vehicle speed or deceleration over time. Due to the proprietary nature of air bag deployment algorithms, the velocity, acceleration, or displacement thresholds for air bag deployment during a collision are not easily obtained; however, a range of frontal barrier impact speeds and corresponding deceleration and displacement threshold values for air bag deployment can be approximated using known vehicle stiffness-to-weight ratios.


10/27/2015· Accident Prevention & Safety

Forensic Clues: Ladder Accidents Part 1 - Stepladders

By: John Ryan, BSME, PE

Ladder accidents occur frequently, often with very serious consequences. Ladders are tools that people use repeatedly, at home and on the job. The CPSC (Consumer Product Safety Commission) states that there are more than 164,000 emergency room-treated injuries annually due to ladders in the United States.

; broker Movie Ad
Unicourt Logo Button

Follow us

linkedin logo youtube logo rss feed logo